Best 3Commas Alternative for TradingView Users (2025)
Quick Summary
Looking for a 3Commas alternative? This comprehensive comparison helps traders frustrated with 3Commas pricing, execution lag, or lack of demo trading find a better solution. TradingView Hub offers testnet trading on Binance, Bybit, and OKX, granular trade command control, dual webhook endpoints for fast execution, and transparent pricing with no bot limits.
For Traders Who Want Control, Not Just Convenience
3Commas has built an impressive platform with 2 million+ registered users. But with recent pricing changes, execution concerns, and a one-size-fits-all bot approach, many traders are looking for alternatives that offer more control.
If you're a TradingView user who wants granular control over your trade signals, the ability to test strategies on real market conditions without risk, or simply transparent pricing without artificial bot limits, this comparison will help you decide if TradingView Hub is the right 3Commas alternative for you.
Bottom line: 3Commas excels at preset bot automation. TradingView Hub is built for traders who want precise control over every trade parameter, fast execution for scalping strategies, and the ability to test on demo accounts before risking real money.
Quick Verdict - TL;DR
The Short Answer: TV-Hub wins on control, demo trading, and transparent pricing
- Demo Trading: TV-Hub supports Binance, Bybit, OKX testnets - test without risking real money
- No Bot Limits: Unlimited strategies vs 3Commas' 5-1000 bots depending on plan
- Fast Execution: 1-3 second endpoint for scalping vs variable 3Commas execution
- Transparent Pricing: 7-day free trial, $23/month (or FREE via referral) vs $12-$92+/month with complex tiers
- Telegram Native: Trade + push notifications for every action (3Commas lacks this)
Master Feature Comparison Matrix
| Feature | TV-Hub | 3Commas |
|---|---|---|
| Demo/Testnet Trading | ✅ Binance, Bybit, OKX testnets | ❌ Demo mode only (paper trading) |
| Trade Command Granularity | ✅ Full control over all parameters | ⚠️ Bot presets with limited customization |
| Bot/Strategy Limits | ✅ Unlimited | ⚠️ 5-1000 depending on plan |
| Fast Execution Endpoint | ✅ 1-3 sec option available | ⚠️ Variable execution times |
| TradingView Integration | ✅ Webhook + Email fallback | ✅ Webhook only |
| Telegram Trading | ✅ Native + push notifications | ❌ Not available |
| Supported Exchanges | 7 major + testnets | 14+ exchanges |
| DCA/Grid Bots Built-in | ❌ Manual via signals | ✅ Automated presets |
| Pricing Transparency | ✅ Single tier, no limits | ⚠️ Complex tiers with limits |
| TradingView Free Plan Compatible | ✅ Email signals work | ❌ Requires TradingView Pro |
Who Should Choose Which Platform?
Choose 3Commas If:
- You want pre-built DCA and Grid bots with minimal setup
- You prefer AI-powered trading suggestions
- You need 14+ exchange support
- You're not comfortable with technical signal configuration
Choose TradingView Hub If:
- You want to test strategies on testnets before risking real money
- You need granular control over every trade parameter
- You're running scalping strategies that need fast execution (1-3 seconds)
- You want transparent pricing without artificial bot limits
- You trade via Telegram and want push notifications
Execution Speed & Reliability
Why This Matters: For scalping and low-timeframe strategies, every second counts. Execution lag can turn profitable trades into losses.
TV-Hub: Dual Endpoint System
Standard Webhook
https://alerts.tv-hub.org
- • 5-10 second execution
- • Best for: Swing trades, higher timeframes
- • Maximum reliability
Fast Execution
https://alerts.tv-hub.org/api/ExecuteTradeSignalClassic
- • 1-3 second execution
- • Best for: Scalping, low timeframe strategies
- • Optimized for speed-critical trades
3Commas: Single Endpoint
Webhook Execution
- • Variable execution times
- • Users report timing differences on live trades
- • Can cause slippage on scalp strategies
"I've been watching live trades and there's always a timing difference in execution. Especially with my scalp-heavy strategy, it's been causing losses."
- Verified 3Commas User
Email Fallback: Your Safety Net
Webhooks can fail. TradingView can have outages. TV-Hub's email fallback catches these glitches automatically, ensuring your signals still execute even when webhooks go down.
Demo & Testnet Trading
Why This Matters: Testing strategies on real market conditions without risking real money is crucial for developing and refining your trading approach.
TV-Hub: Real Testnet Trading
- Binance Demo: Trade with test funds on Binance's official testnet
- Bybit Demo: Full futures testnet support
- OKX Demo: Practice on OKX's demo environment
- Real Market Data: Test with actual market conditions
- No Money at Risk: Perfect for strategy development
3Commas: Limited Demo Mode
- Paper Trading Only: Simulated environment, not real testnets
- Demo Mode: Available but limited functionality
- No Real Testnet: Can't connect to exchange testnets
- AI Backtesting: Historical testing available
Why Testnet Trading Matters
Testnets connect to real exchange infrastructure with real market data - you're just using test funds instead of real money. This means you can validate your entire signal-to-execution pipeline before going live. Paper trading simulations can't catch API timing issues, webhook failures, or execution quirks that only appear in production environments.
Telegram Integration & Notifications
Why This Matters: Modern traders need real-time notifications wherever they are.
TV-Hub Telegram Features:
- Signal Execution: Execute trades directly from Telegram
- Push Notifications: Get notified for every trade action
- Entry Alerts: Know when positions open
- Exit Notifications: Track when trades close
- SL/TP Hit Alerts: Immediate notification on stop loss or take profit
- Copy Trading: Share and follow signals in groups
3Commas Telegram:
- ❌ No native Telegram integration
- ❌ No Telegram trading commands
- ❌ No push notifications via Telegram
- Email/SMS notifications only
Pricing Deep Dive
TV-Hub Plans
| Plan | Price | Features |
|---|---|---|
| Demo | Always free | Testnet trading, no time limit |
| 7-Day Trial | $0 | Full Pro access, no credit card |
| Free | $0 | Full access via exchange referral |
| Pro | $23/month ($19/month with 6-month plan) |
All features, unlimited strategies |
| Enterprise | Custom | White-label, contact support |
3Commas Plans
| Plan | Price | Limitations |
|---|---|---|
| Free | $0 | Demo only, 1 active bot |
| Starter | $12.42/mo | 5 DCA bots, 0 Signal bots, 1 exchange |
| Pro | $30/mo | 20 bots each, 3 exchanges |
| Expert | $91.58/mo | 1000 bots, 15 exchanges |
The Pricing Problem
3Commas has been reducing limits while raising prices. Users report:
- • Same plan now includes 3 bots instead of 20
- • Upgrade from basic ($50) to more bots costs ~$160
- • Signal bots not included in Starter plan at all
- • Legacy users forced to new pricing to access features like AI trading
Why Choose TradingView Hub
Test Before You Trade
- • Binance, Bybit, OKX testnet support
- • Real market conditions, test funds
- • Validate your entire pipeline before going live
Precision Execution
- • Fast 1-3 second endpoint for scalping
- • Email fallback catches webhook failures
- • Dual endpoints for different strategies
Transparent Pricing
- • Demo trading always free - no time limit
- • 7-day free trial - full Pro access, no credit card
- • Free tier via exchange referral
- • Single $23/mo tier - no limits
- • Works with TradingView free plan (email signals)
Full Control
- • Granular trade command parameters
- • Your strategy, your rules
- • No preset bot limitations
See TradingView Hub in Action
Demo trading is always free. Start your 7-day trial for full Pro access - no credit card required.
Start Free Trial View DocumentationWhat Traders Are Saying
"The pricing with my previous service was very expensive, even with Black Friday sales. They keep making it more expensive - for the same plan, you used to have access to 20 active bots, now only 3. The upgrade for more bots is about $160 compared to $50 for the basic plan.
I've been watching live trades and there's always a timing difference in execution. Especially with my scalp-heavy strategy, it's been causing losses. Even with TradingView Premium for real-time market data, there's still execution lag.
What drew me to TradingView Hub was the demo account option - I'm not very tech-savvy but I appreciate being able to test without risking real money. The pricing is also much more transparent."
- Verified 3Commas User, November 2025
"Finally found a platform that lets me control every parameter of my trades. 3Commas bots were too rigid for my strategy."
- Marcus T., Algorithmic Trader
"The testnet trading feature is invaluable. I tested my Pine Script strategy for two weeks on Binance Demo before going live. Caught several issues that would have cost me real money."
- Sarah K., Strategy Developer
Switch from 3Commas in 5 Steps
Step 1: Document Your Current Setup
Export or screenshot your 3Commas bot configurations, TradingView alert setups, and API connections. Note your position sizes, risk parameters, and any custom settings you've configured.
Step 2: Start with Testnet (Recommended)
Before migrating live trading, connect to Binance Demo, Bybit Demo, or OKX Demo on TV-Hub. This lets you validate your entire setup without risk. Most users spend 1-2 weeks testing before going live.
Step 3: Connect Your Exchanges
Follow our detailed documentation to connect your exchange APIs. We support Binance, Bybit, OKX, Coinbase, KuCoin, and BitMex. Each exchange has step-by-step API key setup instructions.
Step 4: Build Your Trade Commands
Configure your strategies using our command builder. Unlike 3Commas' preset bots, you control every parameter: order types, stop-loss, take-profit, position sizing, DCA settings, and more. Copy the generated JSON to your TradingView alert and choose your webhook endpoint (standard or fast execution).
Step 5: Set Up Notifications
Connect Telegram for push notifications on every trade action - entries, exits, SL/TP hits. Enable email fallback to catch any webhook glitches. You'll never miss a signal again.
Most users complete migration in under 30 minutes. The testnet validation step is optional but highly recommended for peace of mind.
Ready to Make the Switch?
Demo trading is always free. Or start your 7-day trial with full Pro access - no credit card required.
Start Free Trial View DocumentationFrequently Asked Questions
Ready to Take Control of Your Trading?
Join 35,000+ traders who chose precision over presets. Demo trading is always free, or start your 7-day Pro trial - no credit card required.
Start Free Trial View Documentation